A Nation Divided: How PSL Fan Rivalries Are Hurting Bafana Bafana.

South African football is a living, breathing force of passion, rivalry, and deep-rooted pride. The electric atmosphere of Soweto derbies pulses through stadiums, while lively debates ignite social media and living rooms alike. Every week, the Premier Soccer League stirs powerful emotions, uniting and dividing fans in equal measure. But recently, these passionate divisions among PSL supporters have begun casting a long, painful shadow over the national team, Bafana Bafana.

Bafana Bafana once stood as a shining symbol of unity, a team that could make an entire nation rise in hope and celebration. Now, however, the national side finds itself trapped in a web of club loyalties, heated fan arguments, and relentless criticism. The weight of these divisions is not just bruising their reputation; it is seeping onto the pitch, eroding the very spirit that once made the team a source of collective pride.

Club Hatred is Spilling into National Team Loyalty

It's normal for fans to support their clubs, whether that's Kaizer Chiefs, Orlando Pirates, Mamelodi Sundowns, or others. However, club rivalries have now become more negative and are spilling over into the national team. Some fans now openly disassociate themselves from Bafana Bafana simply because of the players who are picked or not picked, based on their club affiliation. In online spaces, it's not uncommon to see comments like:

"This is a Sundowns team, not a national team."
"Chiefs players don’t deserve to wear the jersey."
"Pirates fans won’t support this squad; it’s biased."
“It was Pirates players who won us the game.”

This kind of tribalism changes what the national shirt means. Instead of bringing people together, it has become a symbol of personal bias instead of national pride.

Fans Fighting Over Player Selections

Whenever a new Bafana Bafana squad is announced, it causes more arguments than excitement. Fans argue about who should be picked, often focusing on club loyalty instead of player performance. If a Kaizer Chiefs player makes the team, some Sundowns fans complain. If a Pirates striker is left out, people accuse the coach of being unfair. All this fighting is not just loud—it wears everyone down. Players who should be celebrated end up being criticised by their own fans, just for wearing the national jersey.

1. Hugo Broos's Remarks Add Fuel to the Fire

Coach Hugo Broos has done little to calm the storm. His controversial criticism of Kaizer Chiefs, after they drew a match and he accused them of playing "bad football", angered many. Chiefs fans felt disrespected, especially as the national coach is expected to remain neutral and diplomatic.

Ironically, not long after those remarks, Bafana Bafana drew with a struggling 10-man Zimbabwe in a World Cup qualifier, a result far more disappointing than Chiefs' domestic performance. And he didn’t portray it as bad football, but said they were out of luck.

The hypocrisy wasn’t lost on fans. For many, it confirmed the belief that Broos is out of touch or even biased, further alienating large sections of the football community.

2. Are the Players Feeling It Too?

This environment affects players, make no mistake. When you're selected to represent your country and half the fanbase is questioning your merit based on your club, it creates pressure, anxiety, and frustration.

Players are human beings first, and if all they see is negativity, it's only natural that their fighting spirit and morale drop. The fear of being scapegoated after a loss, of being booed not by rivals but by their own people, can be soul-crushing.

How Do We Fix This? Uniting for the Badge

1. South African football needs a cultural reset. Here are a few steps that can start to repair the cracks:

2. National Pride Above Club Loyalty. We must remember that the national team belongs to all of us. Whether a player comes from Chiefs, Pirates, Sundowns, or AmaZulu, they wear one badge: South Africa’s.

3. Hugo Broos must recognise his role not just as a coach, but as a leader. His comments carry weight. Criticism is fair, but public disrespect divides the nation further.

4. Fan pages, podcasts, and sports media should push a message of unity around Bafana Bafana, not amplify toxic club rivalries. Opinions matter, but so does nation-building.

Yes, we expect better performances. Yes, criticism is allowed. But it must be constructive, not hateful or tribal.

Bafana Bafana Once United Us — It Can Again

There was a time, especially during the 1996 AFCON win and the 2010 World Cup, when Bafana Bafana united the country. Different tribes, different languages, different clubs, all sang, danced, and celebrated as one.

We can return to that, but only if we stop fighting each other and start standing with our team.

Because when Bafana Bafana wins, South Africa wins.